Herring: History and Origins

Few fish have shaped the map of Europe as quietly and as powerfully as the herring. A small, oily, silver schooling fish of the cold North Atlantic and Baltic, it was never invented and never had a single discoverer — it was simply there, in immense numbers, when coastal people learned to catch and keep it. This article traces what the documented record actually supports: how herring sustained people from the Stone Age coasts of northern Europe; how the simple problem of keeping a fish that spoils within hours drove the invention of salting, gibbing, smoking, and pickling; how those preserved barrels built medieval trade fairs, the Hanseatic League, and the wealth of the Dutch Golden Age; and how, in the railway and steamship age, the "silver darlings" turned ports in Scotland, England, Scandinavia, and beyond into boom towns. Where the record is firm we say so; where a story is a popular legend — like the "inventor" of gibbing — we name it as legend.

Table of Contents

  1. A Fish of the Northern Seas
  2. Ancient and Early Coastal Use
  3. Salt, Fasting, and the Fish Event Horizon
  4. The Hanseatic League and the Scania Market
  5. Gibbing and the Beukelszoon Legend
  6. The Herring Buss and the Dutch Golden Age
  7. Crown Brand, Kippers, and the British Boom
  8. Curing Traditions and Cultural Significance
  9. Collapse, Recovery, and the Modern Fishery
  10. Research Papers and References
  11. Connections
  12. Featured Videos

A Fish of the Northern Seas

Herring is not a single fish but a small group of closely related species in the genus Clupea. The two that matter most to this history are the Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus), which ranges across the North Atlantic and into the Baltic and North Seas, and the Pacific herring (Clupea pallasii), found along the northern rims of the Pacific from Japan and Korea to Alaska and California. They are open-water schooling fish that gather in spawning aggregations so vast that older accounts describe the sea itself turning silver. Unlike wheat, rice, or cattle, herring was never domesticated; for almost its entire history with people it has been a wild harvest, taken from the sea rather than raised.

That single biological fact — that herring arrive in enormous, predictable shoals at particular places and seasons, then vanish — is the hinge on which this whole story turns. A community that learned where and when the shoals came could, for a few weeks, pull astonishing quantities of food from the water. But herring is also one of the fastest-spoiling fish there is; an oily fish left ungutted in summer heat can be rotten within a day. The history of herring is therefore really two histories braided together: the natural history of where the fish ran, and the human history of how people raced to preserve a glut that would otherwise be lost. Almost every famous herring tradition — the salted barrel, the pickled fillet, the smoked kipper — is an answer to that one problem.

Back to Table of Contents

Ancient and Early Coastal Use

People have been eating herring for as long as they have lived beside the seas where it runs. Because fish bones are small and fragile, the archaeological record is patchy, but herring bones turn up at coastal and estuarine settlement sites in northern Europe going back to prehistory, alongside the bones of other inshore fish. The honest summary is that herring was a familiar coastal food in the Stone Age and later prehistoric north, gathered close to shore by communities that fished the same waters for generations — though for these very early periods we are reading scattered bones, not written records, so the picture is one of long-standing local use rather than organised trade.

What changed herring from a local food into a trade good is now being read directly from the fish themselves. A 2022 study in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences by Lane Atmore, James Barrett, Bastiaan Star and colleagues used ancient DNA recovered from archaeological herring bones to identify which Baltic herring populations were being caught at which sites and times. Their evidence points to long-distance herring trade reaching back to the Viking Age, with herring adapted to the saltier western Baltic appearing at the trading site of Truso, in what is now northeastern Poland, from around the ninth century. In other words, the genetic record shows people were already moving preserved herring across long distances more than a thousand years ago — well before the great medieval fairs that the written sources describe.

Back to Table of Contents

Salt, Fasting, and the Fish Event Horizon

Around the year 1000 AD, something shifted in how Europeans got their fish. Studying fish bones from English archaeological sites, James Barrett, Alison Locker, and Callum Roberts identified a rapid change from freshwater fish toward sea fish — herring and cod above all — happening over a remarkably short span around the end of the tenth and start of the eleventh centuries. They named this turn the "fish event horizon," and argued it marked the real beginning of intensive marine fishing in medieval Europe. Several pressures seem to have come together to drive it: growing populations, expanding towns, the pollution and over-fishing of inland rivers, and the steady reach of Christian dietary rules.

Those religious rules mattered enormously. The medieval Church set aside a great many fast days — Fridays, the season of Lent, and other observances — on which the flesh of warm-blooded animals was forbidden but fish was allowed. Across a year this could add up to well over a hundred meatless days, and across a whole continent that created a colossal, reliable demand for fish. Herring, abundant and cheap, became one of the great answers to that demand. But demand alone could not have built a trade: the fish had to survive the journey from the sea to an inland monastery or market town. The key technology was salt. Heavily salted and packed in barrels, herring would keep for months, and salt-herring became one of the first true mass-traded foods of Europe — a preserved protein that could travel hundreds of miles and feed people far from any coast.

Back to Table of Contents

The Hanseatic League and the Scania Market

By the high Middle Ages the herring trade had grown into one of the largest commodity businesses in Europe, and its centre of gravity sat in the western Baltic. Each autumn, herring shoaled in the narrow Øresund strait between what are now Denmark and Sweden, and on the beaches of the Scania (Skåne) coast a vast seasonal market sprang up to process the catch. Contemporary and historical estimates of its scale are staggering: very large numbers of barrels of salted herring were packed there each season, and fleets of ships carried them across northern Europe. The Scania Market became the most important fish market in northern Europe in the fourteenth century.

The merchants who organised and profited from this trade were above all those of the Hanseatic League, the powerful confederation of northern German trading towns led by Lübeck. The Hansa's control rested on a simple, decisive fact: you could not preserve herring without salt, and the Hansa controlled the great salt sources, especially the salt of Lüneburg. By supplying the salt and the barrels to the Scania beaches, financing the curing, and shipping the finished barrels onward, Hanseatic merchants turned the herring run into the backbone of their commercial empire, distributing salted herring from England to Poland and from Scandinavia to the Low Countries. The herring barrel was, for a time, one of the most important units of trade in the north. The 2022 ancient-DNA work mentioned earlier also reads, in the genes of the fish, the long-term mark of this intensive harvest — a pattern consistent with serial depletion of herring stocks under sustained medieval and early-modern fishing pressure.

Back to Table of Contents

Gibbing and the Beukelszoon Legend

One preservation technique deserves its own section, because it changed the economics of the entire trade and because it carries one of food history's most famous legends. The technique is gibbing (Dutch kaken): with a single deft cut, the gills and part of the gullet are removed from the fresh herring, which also takes away the bitter-tasting parts, while the liver and pancreas are deliberately left in place. Enzymes from those organs then help cure and flavour the fish as it sits in salt in the barrel. Gibbing let herring be gutted, salted, and barrelled right on the deck of the boat, at sea, within an hour or two of being caught — producing a far better and longer-keeping product than fish hauled ashore before processing.

Dutch tradition credits the invention of gibbing to a fourteenth-century fisherman named Willem Beukelszoon (sometimes anglicised William Buckels) from Biervliet in Zeeland, and he became a national folk hero for it. This is a legend, and historians treat it as one. There is no firm record of exactly when this Beukelszoon lived or precisely what he did, and gibbing as a method was certainly not invented in the Netherlands or by a single Dutchman — preserving fish by gutting and salting is far older and far more widespread than any one person. What is fair to say is that gibbing became closely associated with Dutch herring practice and was central to the rise of the Dutch fishery; the named "inventor" is a national origin story, not documented fact, and this page presents it that way.

Back to Table of Contents

The Herring Buss and the Dutch Golden Age

Gibbing at sea made possible a new kind of vessel, and that vessel made possible an empire of fish. The herring buss (Dutch haringbuis) was, in effect, a floating factory: a sturdy seagoing boat on which crews could catch herring with drift nets, gib and salt them on deck, and pack them into barrels far from land, staying out to follow the shoals for weeks. The first herring busses are generally said to have been built in the Netherlands in the early fifteenth century, around 1415, and over the next two centuries the fleet grew into the heart of what the Dutch called the Great Fishery (Groote Visscherij).

At its height in the first half of the seventeenth century — the Dutch Golden Age — the herring fleet numbered on the order of several hundred busses, landing tens of thousands of tonnes of cured herring a year. This was not a quaint coastal industry but one of the engines of Dutch prosperity: it employed huge numbers of people on the boats and in the curing, cooperage, net-making, and shipping trades ashore, and it earned vast sums abroad. In the off-season the same busses were turned to ordinary cargo work, carrying Baltic grain or Portuguese salt, which made the whole enterprise more profitable still. It is no exaggeration that herring helped underwrite the rise of the Dutch Republic; an old Dutch saying held that Amsterdam was built on herring bones. For a long period the Dutch dominated the European herring trade and the many refined varieties of cured herring that came with it.

Back to Table of Contents

Crown Brand, Kippers, and the British Boom

For centuries the Dutch led; in the nineteenth century the British surged. A turning point came when the British government set up a Fishery Board (established in 1809) whose officers inspected cured herring and stamped quality barrels with a "crown brand." That guarantee of consistent quality let Scottish cured herring compete directly with the Dutch in the markets of northern Europe, and it helped touch off an extraordinary boom. Through the 1800s and into the early 1900s the herring fishery became one of the great industries of the Scottish and English coasts, with the catch nicknamed the "silver darlings."

The boom is remembered above all for the "herring girls" (or herring lasses) — crews of women, some as young as fourteen, who followed the fleet down the coast from northern Scotland to Great Yarmouth and Lowestoft in East Anglia as the season moved south, gutting and salt-packing the catch at astonishing speed on the quaysides. Thousands made this annual migration, often by special chartered trains. This was also the era of the modern kipper: the split, cold-smoked herring credited to John Woodger, a fish-curer of Seahouses in Northumberland, around 1843. The kipper was very much a product of its time — the railways could rush a mild, lightly smoked fish inland to be eaten for breakfast across Victorian Britain. (Smoking fish itself is, of course, ancient; what Woodger is credited with is the particular kippering style, not the idea of smoking.)

Back to Table of Contents

Curing Traditions and Cultural Significance

Because every herring culture had to solve the same spoilage problem, each developed its own distinctive cured forms, and these have become cherished regional foods in their own right. In the Netherlands, lightly salted young "new herring" — Hollandse Nieuwe or maatjesharing — is eaten raw, traditionally lifted by the tail, often with chopped onion, and the arrival of the season's first catch is still a small national celebration. In Scandinavia, salted and pickled herring (Swedish sill and the fermented surströmming, Norwegian and Danish sild) is fixed at the centre of festive tables, especially at Christmas and Midsummer. In Germany and along the Baltic, rollmops (pickled herring rolled around onion or pickle) and the marinated Bismarck herring are classic. In Britain, the kipper became a breakfast institution, while in Jewish cooking salt herring, schmaltz herring, and chopped herring became staples of the Ashkenazi table.

The Bismarck herring carries a small story worth telling carefully. By popular account, marinated herring came to be named after the German statesman Otto von Bismarck after a Baltic fish merchant in Stralsund sent him barrels of pickled herring and was granted permission to use his name — a naming that fits the late-nineteenth-century fashion for honouring the chancellor in dish names. Like many such food-naming tales the exact details are reported with some variation and are best treated as a popular account rather than firmly documented history; what is not in doubt is that "Bismarck herring" became, and remains, a real and well-known German preparation. Across all these traditions the underlying pattern is the same: a fish too perishable to keep fresh was transformed, by salt, vinegar, and smoke, into foods so distinctive that they outlived the necessity that created them and became markers of regional and cultural identity.

Back to Table of Contents

Collapse, Recovery, and the Modern Fishery

Herring's modern history is a cautionary tale about the limits of even the most abundant wild harvest. Through the twentieth century, ever more powerful boats, engines, and nets allowed catches on a scale earlier fishers could not have imagined — and several great herring stocks were fished to the brink. The most dramatic case was the North Sea herring, whose stock collapsed so severely that the fishery was effectively closed in the late 1970s to let the fish recover. Other stocks, including herring in the Baltic and the famous Norwegian spring-spawning herring, suffered their own crashes in the same era. The genetic record reaches even further back: the ancient-DNA studies discussed earlier read a pattern of repeated, long-running pressure on Baltic herring stretching across centuries, a reminder that over-exploitation is not only a modern problem.

The closures, however painful, became a landmark in fisheries management. With fishing halted or strictly limited, North Sea herring eventually recovered, and the episode helped establish the modern approach of science-based quotas and the precautionary management of shared stocks. Today many North Atlantic and Pacific herring fisheries are managed with catch limits and, in a number of cases, certified against sustainability standards, although stock health still varies by region and remains a live scientific and political question. The arc of herring's story is therefore unusually complete: from a wild glut on a Stone Age beach, through the salted barrels that built medieval fairs and a Golden Age, to the over-fishing, collapse, and careful rebuilding of the present — the same silver fish, still running in the cold northern seas, now harvested under a far more watchful eye.

Back to Table of Contents

Research Papers and References

The list below combines peer-reviewed studies on the history and archaeology of herring fishing with curated PubMed topic-search links and reputable food- and fisheries-history resources. Historical sources named in the article — medieval fasting regulations, the Hanseatic and Scania trade, and the folk traditions surrounding gibbing and named cured herrings — are discussed as history rather than as medical claims. Author names, titles, and journals are given as plain text; only the stable DOI, PMID, or archive link is hyperlinked, and each opens in a new tab.

  1. Barrett JH, Locker AM, Roberts CM. The origins of intensive marine fishing in medieval Europe: the English evidence. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2004;271(1556):2417-2421. — doi:10.1098/rspb.2004.2885
  2. Atmore LM, Martínez-García L, Makowiecki D, André C, Lõugas L, Barrett JH, Star B. Population dynamics of Baltic herring since the Viking Age revealed by ancient DNA and genomics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA. 2022;119(45):e2208703119. — doi:10.1073/pnas.2208703119 · PMID: 36282902
  3. Holm P, Nicholls J, Hayes PW, Ivinson J, Allaire B. Accelerated extractions of North Atlantic cod and herring, 1520-1790. Fish and Fisheries. 2022;23(1):54-72. — doi:10.1111/faf.12598
  4. Herring fishery history and the medieval fish trade — PubMed: herring fishery history and medieval trade
  5. Herring stock collapse, over-exploitation, and fisheries management — PubMed: herring stock collapse and management

External Authoritative Resources

Back to Table of Contents

Connections

Back to Table of Contents