Cabbage Goitrogens, Vitamin K and Tolerance

Three cautions get attached to cabbage more often than any others: it will harm your thyroid, it will interfere with your blood thinner, and it will make you bloated. Each of these has a real mechanism behind it, and each is routinely stated at a level of alarm the evidence does not support. This page takes them one at a time and answers each with a number and a threshold rather than a warning — because the honest picture is that the thyroid concern needs an extreme, sustained raw intake plus low iodine before it means anything, the warfarin issue is about consistency rather than avoidance, and the bloating is real, dose-dependent and largely fixable.


Table of Contents

  1. The Short Version
  2. What a Goitrogen Actually Does
  3. How Much Cabbage It Would Take
  4. The Case Reports, in Context
  5. Who Has Reason to Pay Attention
  6. Cooking and Fermenting Change the Picture
  7. Vitamin K: How Much Cabbage Actually Contains
  8. Warfarin: Consistency, Not Avoidance
  9. The Newer Blood Thinners
  10. Gas, Bloating and FODMAPs
  11. Other Practical Notes
  12. Key Research Papers
  13. Connections
  14. Featured Videos

The Short Version

If you want the conclusions before the reasoning:

What a Goitrogen Actually Does

"Goitrogen" is a loose term for anything that interferes with the making of thyroid hormone. In cruciferous vegetables, two distinct compounds derived from glucosinolates are responsible, and they work by different routes.

Thiocyanate. Some glucosinolate breakdown produces the thiocyanate ion, which is chemically similar in size and charge to iodide. Your thyroid takes up iodide from the blood using a transporter called the sodium-iodide symporter, and thiocyanate competes for that transporter. When thiocyanate is abundant and iodide is scarce, less iodide gets into the gland. Note the shape of that sentence: this is competition, so the outcome depends on the ratio, and plenty of iodide simply wins.

Goitrin. A glucosinolate called progoitrin breaks down to goitrin, which acts further down the line by inhibiting thyroid peroxidase — the enzyme that attaches iodine to thyroglobulin to build the hormone. This is a genuine enzyme inhibition rather than a competition, and it is the more potent of the two effects. The important detail is that cabbage is comparatively low in progoitrin. Certain kale varieties, Brussels sprouts and some brassica forage crops carry considerably more, and the historical veterinary literature on goitre in livestock grazing brassica fodder is where much of this concern originated.

Both routes converge on the same conclusion: the effect is about iodine supply as much as it is about cabbage. In an iodine-replete person, the thyroid has ample substrate and considerable reserve capacity, and neither mechanism has anything to bite on.

How Much Cabbage It Would Take

Felker, Bunch and Leung asked this question directly. They reviewed published measurements of goitrin and thiocyanate precursor concentrations in the brassica vegetables people actually eat, estimated the resulting plasma concentrations, and compared those against the levels known to affect thyroid function.

Their conclusion was reassuring for ordinary eating. For the common brassica vegetables consumed in normal portions, the estimated plasma concentrations sit well below the range associated with any measurable effect on the thyroid. In their figures, radioiodine uptake by the thyroid is inhibited by 194 µmol of goitrin but not by 77 µmol. Collards, Brussels sprouts and some Russian kale (Brassica napus) contain enough goitrin to potentially decrease iodine uptake, while turnip tops, commercial broccoli, broccoli rabe and kale belonging to Brassica oleracea contain less than 10 µmol of goitrin per 100-g serving and can be considered of minimal risk. They estimated the most thiocyanate that indole glucosinolates could add to the blood at 10 µM, well below the background plasma level of 40–69 µM. The exception they identified was specific and narrow: the varieties richest in goitrin. Concentrated brassica juices are the easiest way to take in large amounts, because a large volume of raw vegetable is consumed in a form that is easy to over-consume. A green juice made from several hundred grams of raw kale is a very different exposure from a bowl of coleslaw.

A small human feeding study tested the cooked side of this directly. Ten volunteers added 150 g of cooked Brussels sprouts a day to their normal diet for 4 weeks. The sprouts contained high concentrations of glucosinolates (220 mg per 100 g), yet thyroid function, measured by thyrotrophic hormone (TSH), thyroxine and tri-iodothyronine, did not change. The authors suggested this was because cooking inactivates myrosinase, the enzyme that breaks glucosinolates down into goitrogenic compounds.

Two things follow from this that are worth holding onto:

  1. Portion size is the variable, not the vegetable. Nobody develops thyroid trouble from a serving of cabbage with dinner. The reported problems involve intakes an order of magnitude larger, sustained for months.
  2. Raw juicing is the highest-risk form, not because juice is sinister, but because it is the only realistic way to consume a kilogram of raw brassica in a day. For people who drink large daily raw cruciferous smoothies, that is the habit the concern applies to — not cabbage in general.

The Case Reports, in Context

The case that gets cited whenever this topic comes up appeared in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2010: an elderly woman who developed myxoedema coma — the most severe form of hypothyroidism — after eating very large quantities of raw bok choy every day for several months, on the order of a kilogram or more daily, in the belief it would help her diabetes. She had other health problems and was frail.

It is a real, properly documented case, and it is also a single case. A single case report describes what can happen at an extreme, not what is likely at any ordinary intake. Three features of it matter:

The correct lesson is not "cabbage is dangerous." It is "any single food eaten in extreme quantity as a self-prescribed medicine can cause harm," which is a much older and more generally useful lesson.

Beyond case reports, Truong and colleagues' countrywide case-control study in New Caledonia, comparing 293 women with thyroid cancer and 354 women without it, found an association between cruciferous vegetable intake and thyroid cancer risk that was concentrated in women with low iodine intake (odds ratio 1.86; 95% CI 1.01 to 3.43 for iodine intake below 96 micrograms a day) — again pointing at iodine status as the variable that decides whether cruciferous intake matters at all. The authors noted that Melanesian women, a group with mild iodine deficiency, eat a lot of cruciferous vegetables, which may help explain their exceptionally high rate of thyroid cancer.

Across the wider literature, a 2014 meta-analysis that gathered 19 observational studies of diet and thyroid cancer found no significant link with cruciferous vegetables: comparing the highest with the lowest intake, the summary odds ratio was 0.93 (95% CI 0.66 to 1.29).

Who Has Reason to Pay Attention

Almost nobody needs to change what they eat. The short list of people for whom this is worth a moment's thought:

Cooking and Fermenting Change the Picture

Everything on the glucosinolate chemistry page applies here in reverse. The compounds that raise the thyroid question are made by the same enzyme reaction that makes the compounds people eat cruciferous vegetables for. Anything that reduces one reduces the other.

There is a genuine trade-off here and it is worth naming rather than pretending it away: the preparation that maximises the beneficial isothiocyanates is the same one that maximises the goitrogens. For essentially everyone, that trade is overwhelmingly worth making, because the benefits are available at ordinary intakes and the thyroid effect is not. For the narrow group above, cooking most of the cruciferous vegetables is a simple and complete answer.

Vitamin K: How Much Cabbage Actually Contains

Cabbage's reputation as a "high vitamin K food" is somewhat inflated by association with leafy greens generally. The numbers put it in perspective.

USDA FoodData Central lists 76.0 micrograms of vitamin K1 (phylloquinone) per 100 g of raw cabbage (11 samples, range 56.6 to 131) and 38.2 micrograms per 100 g of raw red cabbage, so red cabbage contains substantially less. For comparison, kale and spinach run into the hundreds of micrograms per 100 g — several times cabbage's level. The adult adequate intake is around 120 micrograms a day for men and 90 for women, so a good serving of cabbage makes a real contribution without being anywhere near the top of the list. (Specific varieties are listed at U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) FoodData Central.)

For anyone not taking a vitamin K antagonist, this is purely good news. Vitamin K1 is required for normal blood clotting and contributes to bone metabolism, and most people's intake is unremarkable rather than generous. See Vitamin K.

Warfarin: Consistency, Not Avoidance

Warfarin works by blocking the recycling of vitamin K, which the liver needs to produce several clotting factors. The dose is calibrated against a person's habitual vitamin K intake. That single sentence contains the whole of the practical point: it is a change in intake that destabilises the international normalized ratio, not the intake itself.

Booth and Centurelli's practical guide made this point for clinicians decades ago, and the evidence since has strengthened it in a direction that surprises people:

What the research points to: a habitual amount of green vegetables kept roughly steady week to week. A daily serving of cabbage or salad is entirely compatible with warfarin; what causes trouble is going from none for a fortnight to a large kale salad every day. Anticoagulation clinics recheck the dose when a diet genuinely changes — a new diet, a hospital stay, a holiday — and starting or stopping a large daily green juice counts as a diet change.

The Newer Blood Thinners

This section exists because the confusion is so common. Apixaban, rivaroxaban, edoxaban and dabigatran are not vitamin K antagonists. They inhibit specific clotting factors directly and have no relationship to dietary vitamin K at all. There is no international normalized ratio to destabilise and no dietary restriction on green vegetables.

For people told years ago to watch their greens on warfarin and since switched to one of these, that instruction no longer applies; the pharmacology is unambiguous.

Gas, Bloating and FODMAPs

This is the complaint that actually stops people eating cabbage, and unlike the other two it is common and genuine.

Cabbage contains carbohydrates that human digestive enzymes cannot break down — principally fructans and raffinose-family oligosaccharides. They pass intact into the colon, where bacteria ferment them and produce gas. Add the sulfur compounds discussed elsewhere on this site, and some of that gas is hydrogen sulfide, which accounts for the distinctive smell.

These carbohydrates fall under the FODMAP umbrella. Muir and colleagues measured short-chain carbohydrate content across common vegetables, providing the underlying data, and Halmos and colleagues' randomised trial demonstrated that reducing overall FODMAP intake reduces symptoms in irritable bowel syndrome. Cabbage is not among the worst offenders — a modest serving is usually tolerated, and it is larger portions that push it into problem territory — but for a sensitive gut it is a real contributor.

What people report helps, roughly in order of effectiveness:

  1. Cooking. Cooked cabbage is markedly better tolerated than raw. A big raw slaw is a much bigger fermentable load than the same weight braised.
  2. Starting small and building up. The gut microbial community adapts over weeks. People who eat vegetables regularly tolerate them better, and that is an adaptation, not a personality trait.
  3. Smaller portions rather than fewer days. A modest amount every day is generally better tolerated than a large amount twice a week.
  4. Chewing properly and eating slowly. Swallowed air is a bigger part of bloating than most people credit.
  5. Fermented cabbage. The bacteria in sauerkraut and kimchi consume some of the fermentable carbohydrates before the cabbage is ever eaten. Many people who cannot manage a plate of boiled cabbage do fine with a few forkfuls of sauerkraut. (Two caveats: fermented foods are high in sodium, and a minority of people are sensitive to the histamine and other amines that build up during fermentation.)
  6. Enzyme supplements. Alpha-galactosidase preparations, sold for beans, target exactly the raffinose-family sugars in cabbage. They help some people and do nothing for others, and they are cheap.

If bloating is severe, persistent, or comes with weight loss, blood in the stool, or a change in bowel habit that does not settle, those are warning signs that doctors investigate, not a cabbage problem. See Gastroenterology.

Other Practical Notes

Key Research Papers

  1. Felker P, Bunch R, Leung AM. Concentrations of thiocyanate and goitrin in human plasma, their precursor concentrations in brassica vegetables, and associated potential risk for hypothyroidism. Nutrition Reviews. 2016;74(4):248–258. — doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuv110
  2. McMillan M, Spinks EA, Fenwick GR. Preliminary observations on the effect of dietary brussels sprouts on thyroid function. Human Toxicology. 1986;5(1):15–19. — doi:10.1177/096032718600500104
  3. Zimmermann MB, Boelaert K. Iodine deficiency and thyroid disorders. The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology. 2015;3(4):286–295. — doi:10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70225-6
  4. Truong T, Baron-Dubourdieu D, Rougier Y, GuĂ©nel P. Role of dietary iodine and cruciferous vegetables in thyroid cancer: a countrywide case-control study in New Caledonia. Cancer Causes & Control. 2010;21(8):1183–1192. — doi:10.1007/s10552-010-9545-2
  5. Liu ZT, Lin AH. Dietary factors and thyroid cancer risk: a meta-analysis of observational studies. Nutrition and Cancer. 2014;66(7):1165–1178. — doi:10.1080/01635581.2014.951734
  6. Chu M, Seltzer TF. Myxedema coma induced by ingestion of raw bok choy. New England Journal of Medicine. 2010;362(20):1945–1946. — PubMed PMID: 20484407
  7. Bajaj JK, Salwan P, Salwan S. Various possible toxicants involved in thyroid dysfunction: a review. Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research. 2016;10(1):FE01–FE03. — doi:10.7860/JCDR/2016/15195.7092
  8. Booth SL, Centurelli MA. Vitamin K: a practical guide to the dietary management of patients on warfarin. Nutrition Reviews. 1999;57(9):288–296. — doi:10.1111/j.1753-4887.1999.tb01815.x
  9. Sconce E, Khan T, Mason J, Noble F, Wynne H, Kamali F. Patients with unstable control have a poorer dietary intake of vitamin K compared to patients with stable control of anticoagulation. Thrombosis and Haemostasis. 2005;93(5):872–875. — doi:10.1160/TH04-12-0773
  10. Rombouts EK, Rosendaal FR, van der Meer FJM. Daily vitamin K supplementation improves anticoagulant stability. Journal of Thrombosis and Haemostasis. 2007;5(10):2043–2048. — doi:10.1111/j.1538-7836.2007.02715.x
  11. Violi F, Lip GY, Pignatelli P, Pastori D. Interaction between dietary vitamin K intake and anticoagulation by vitamin K antagonists: is it really true? Medicine. 2016;95(10):e2895. — doi:10.1097/MD.0000000000002895
  12. Muir JG, Rose R, Rosella O, et al. Measurement of short-chain carbohydrates in common Australian vegetables and fruits by high-performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2009;57(2):554–565. — doi:10.1021/jf802700e
  13. Halmos EP, Power VA, Shepherd SJ, Gibson PR, Muir JG. A diet low in FODMAPs reduces symptoms of irritable bowel syndrome. Gastroenterology. 2014;146(1):67–75.e5. — doi:10.1053/j.gastro.2013.09.046
  14. Verkerk R, Schreiner M, Krumbein A, et al. Glucosinolates in Brassica vegetables: the influence of the food supply chain on intake, bioavailability and human health. Molecular Nutrition & Food Research. 2009;53(Suppl 2):S219. — doi:10.1002/mnfr.200800065
  15. Rungapamestry V, Duncan AJ, Fuller Z, Ratcliffe B. Effect of cooking brassica vegetables on the subsequent hydrolysis and metabolic fate of glucosinolates. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society. 2007;66(1):69–81. — doi:10.1017/S0029665107005319

Further reading: PubMed: goitrogens, cruciferous vegetables and iodine and PubMed: dietary vitamin K and International Normalized Ratio stability.

Back to Table of Contents

Connections

Back to Table of Contents