Fish-Stunning, Oral Exposure and the Dose Gap

The single most common argument for jewel vine's safety is not a study — it is an inference from tradition: people have caught and eaten tuba-stunned fish for centuries across Southeast Asia, without recorded mass poisoning, so the plant "must" be safe. The parent page names this argument and states its conclusion is wrong. This article does the arithmetic behind that conclusion, using real, published concentration and clearance data rather than assertion, and then extends the same honest treatment to two pieces of newer literature — a genuine 2023 ethnobotanical report and a 2024 rat study — that a search engine might surface as apparent evidence of internal use, and that deserve exactly the same non-dispositive, non-alarmist scrutiny.


Table of Contents

  1. The Short Answer
  2. The Practice, Briefly
  3. Where the "The Fish Were Eaten" Argument Breaks
  4. How Fast Rotenone Actually Disappears From Treated Water
  5. Where It Goes: Sediment, Tissue and No Bioaccumulation
  6. Oral Pharmacokinetics: Why Route Changes Everything
  7. Printing the Gap: Root Concentration Versus Water Concentration
  8. A Genuine 2023 Ethnobotanical Report, and What It Does and Doesn't Establish
  9. A 2024 Rat Study, and Why It Doesn't Change the Verdict
  10. What This Page Is Not Claiming
  11. Numbered Findings: What Is Not Known
  12. Key Research Papers
  13. External Resources
  14. Connections
  15. Featured Videos

The Short Answer

Eating a fish stunned with dilute rotenone in a stream or pool is not evidence that eating the root, or a concentrated rotenone product, is safe. The water concentrations used to stun fish are deliberately low, they fall further before a fish is caught and cooked, rotenone does not concentrate in fish flesh above the surrounding water, and mammalian gut absorption and liver metabolism handle a swallowed dose very differently from a fish's gill-absorbed one. Two newer pieces of published research — a 2023 report of internal use by one Indigenous community and a 2024 rat study of a leaf extract — are real, and neither of them changes that conclusion, for reasons explained in full below.

Back to Table of Contents

The Practice, Briefly

The parent page describes tuba fishing in detail: pounded Derris elliptica root is swirled through a dammed section of slow-moving stream or a tidal pool, the fish lose coordination within minutes and rise to the surface, and they are collected by hand or basket — then eaten. This is a real, historically and culturally significant practice across Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Papua New Guinea and the Pacific, and it is not in dispute. What is in dispute is the inference some readers draw from it: that centuries of apparently uneventful fish-eating proves the plant is safe to consume more directly. This article is about why that specific inference fails, not about whether the practice happened or whether the fish were genuinely eaten — they were.

Back to Table of Contents

Where the "The Fish Were Eaten" Argument Breaks

Laid out as a syllogism, the argument runs: (1) rotenone-stunned fish were eaten for centuries; (2) no mass poisoning from this practice is recorded; (3) therefore rotenone, and by extension the root that produces it, is safe for humans to consume. The conclusion does not follow, because premise (1) smuggles in an assumption the rest of this article tests directly: that the dose a person receives from eating a stunned fish is comparable, or even in the same broad range, to the dose in a mouthful of root or a rotenone-based product. It is not. The remainder of this article establishes, with real published numbers, three separate reasons the fish-eating dose is dramatically smaller than the root or product dose: concentration (how much rotenone was ever in the water to begin with), clearance (how much of that remains by the time a fish is caught and cooked), and route (how the body handles a swallowed dose differently from a gill-absorbed one). Each is real, measured science, not a rhetorical move to dismiss the tradition.

Back to Table of Contents

How Fast Rotenone Actually Disappears From Treated Water

Modern fisheries-management applications of rotenone are the best-documented, most precisely measured analogue available for what happens in a tuba-fishing pool, because regulators require exactly this kind of monitoring before and after a treatment. Three real field and laboratory studies give concrete numbers:

A tropical tuba-fishing pool — shallow, sun-exposed, warm — sits closer to the fast, sunlight-driven end of this range than to a deep temperate lake. The parent page's statement that "sunlight and warm water break it down within days" is consistent with, and now backed by, these real measurements.

Back to Table of Contents

Where It Goes: Sediment, Tissue and No Bioaccumulation

The Lake Davis study's most important finding for this article is not the half-life number itself but what it says about fish tissue specifically: rotenone and its metabolite rotenolone persisted somewhat longer in sediment and tissue than in water — not detectable in sediment after 157 days, and below detection in tissue within 212 days — but critically, "none of the constituents was found to bioaccumulate in tissues as a result of treatment." Bioaccumulation is the process by which a chemical concentrates in an organism's tissue to levels higher than in its surrounding environment, the way mercury concentrates up a food chain. Rotenone did not do this in Lake Davis. From that finding, this page infers that a fish's tissue concentration does not build up above the water concentration it was exposed to; the study itself did not report tissue levels as matching water levels, and the fish it tested were a rotenone-resistant species.

That single finding does most of the work in this article. By this page's inference (not a measurement the study reports), a fish caught during or shortly after a tuba treatment carries a body burden in roughly the same low concentration range as the water it was swimming in — not a concentrated dose built up over the fish's tissues, which is the scenario that would actually be dangerous.

Back to Table of Contents

Oral Pharmacokinetics: Why Route Changes Everything

A 2021 Chemical Research in Toxicology review by Innos and Hickey, specifically examining the pharmacokinetics behind rotenone's use as a Parkinson's disease research tool, states plainly that "rotenone is metabolized extensively in vivo, and choice of route of exposure influences greatly the dose used." The parent page's account of gill absorption versus mammalian first-pass metabolism is the mechanistic explanation for exactly this review's conclusion: a fish absorbs a dissolved, lipophilic molecule directly across its gills into arterial blood, while a mammal swallowing the same molecule sends it through the gut wall and then the liver's cytochrome P450 system before much of it reaches systemic circulation at all. The same review also confirms, from the toxicological literature it surveys, that "rotenone degrades when exposed to light or water" — the mechanism behind the half-life figures above — and notes that even the vehicle a dose is dissolved in measurably changes the outcome in laboratory rotenone-poisoning models, which is a further reason a stunned fish's low-concentration, water-borne exposure is not a stand-in for a concentrated oral dose of root or product.

Long-term exposure is a separate question from a single swallowed dose. In a US case-control study nested in the Agricultural Health Study (110 people with Parkinson's disease and 358 controls), lifetime use of rotenone as a pesticide was associated with Parkinson's disease (odds ratio 2.5; 95% confidence interval 1.3–4.7).

Back to Table of Contents

This site's evidence doctrine calls for printing the arithmetic behind a safety or danger claim rather than asserting a conclusion, so that a reader can check it. Here is the comparison, using only figures already established on this site or sourced above, and comparing like with like — oral-route concentrations against other oral-route concentrations, not water concentrations against body-weight doses, which are not directly comparable units.

Comparing the root's own rotenone concentration (10,000–50,000 ppm) to a treated pool's water concentration and the fish tissue inferred to follow it (well under 1 ppm, and falling) gives a gap on the order of four to five orders of magnitude — a ten-thousand-fold-or-greater difference in concentration, before oral bioavailability and first-pass metabolism reduce the fish-eating exposure even further. That gap, not any special property of fish digestion, is the real reason centuries of tuba-fishing did not produce mass poisoning while the case reports on the parent page describe real deaths from concentrated root or product. This arithmetic describes a gap; it is not a calculation of any "safe" amount of root or rotenone product to consume — no such amount has been established, and the parent page is explicit that none should be sought.

Back to Table of Contents

A Genuine 2023 Ethnobotanical Report, and What It Does and Doesn't Establish

A 2023 Journal of Ethnopharmacology paper documented the medicinal plant knowledge of the Kenyah community of Sarawak, Borneo, based on interviews with 24 respondents across four longhouses. Of 61 plant species recorded, only seven were cited by more than 20% of respondents, and the paper specifically flagged four species used for indications "scarcely reported" in the existing ethnobotanical literature. Derris elliptica was one of them — recorded by the Kenyah as a treatment for fever and influenza.

This is real, recent, peer-reviewed field data, and it deserves to be taken seriously as a documented practice rather than dismissed. It is worth being precise about what it does and does not establish:

Back to Table of Contents

A 2024 Rat Study, and Why It Doesn't Change the Verdict

A 2024 Saudi Pharmaceutical Journal paper investigated the "therapeutic potential" of a Derris elliptica methanolic leaf extract in streptozotocin-induced diabetic Sprague Dawley rats. Rats received 200 or 400 mg/kg of the extract orally for 14 days, alongside acute oral toxicity testing in normal rats. The study reported no signs of toxicity or mortality, a significant reduction in blood glucose and body weight, reduced total cholesterol, increased insulin secretion at the higher dose, and improved liver-enzyme markers — concluding that the extract "may have therapeutic potential for the treatment of diabetes mellitus."

This is a real, peer-reviewed paper, not a fabrication, and it deserves the same direct treatment as the ethnobotanical finding above: taken seriously, and precisely contextualised, rather than either hidden or credited more than it earns.

Back to Table of Contents

What This Page Is Not Claiming

Back to Table of Contents

Numbered Findings: What Is Not Known

  1. The rotenoid content of the leaf extract used in the 2024 diabetic-rat study, compared directly to root material from the same plant population, was not located — the part-substitution argument above is a plausible inference from established plant chemistry, not a directly measured comparison.
  2. The exact preparation, dose, frequency and part used in the Kenyah fever/influenza practice are not specified in the source this site could verify.
  3. No pharmacovigilance or case-series follow-up on the Kenyah practice was located, so its real-world safety record, positive or negative, is unmonitored rather than established.
  4. A direct, controlled comparison of fish-tissue rotenone concentration immediately after a tuba-fishing treatment, using modern analytical methods, was not located — the figures used above come from regulated modern fisheries-management treatments, which is the closest available analogue but not an identical practice.
  5. No human oral pharmacokinetic study of rotenone at any dose was located. The absorption and metabolism discussion above draws on animal pharmacokinetic data and general toxicological principles, not a human trial.

What is known about swallowed rotenone in people comes mainly from poisoning reports. A 2024 scoping review of acute rotenone poisoning screened 2,631 publications and identified 11 case reports describing 18 victims, 15 of whom were hospitalised and five of whom died. Most cases occurred in private homes, where the victims unknowingly ate rotenone-containing plants. Vomiting and metabolic acidosis (a build-up of acid in the blood) were the most common signs. There is no antidote, and treatment is supportive. The reviewers add that cases may be under-diagnosed because the symptoms are non-specific, and under-reported in English-language journals because most cases occurred in non-English-speaking countries.

Back to Table of Contents

Key Research Papers

  1. Innos J, Hickey MA. Using rotenone to model Parkinson's disease in mice: a review of the role of pharmacokinetics. Chemical Research in Toxicology. 2021;34(5):1223-1239. — PubMed PMID: 33961406
  2. Finlayson BJ, Eilers JM, Huchko HA. Fate and behavior of rotenone in Diamond Lake, Oregon, USA following invasive tui chub eradication. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. 2014;33(7):1650-1655. — 4.5-day water half-life. — PubMed PMID: 24733691
  3. Vasquez ME, Rinderneck J, Newman J, McMillin S, Finlayson B, Mekebri A, Crane D, Tjeerdema RS. Rotenone formulation fate in Lake Davis following the 2007 treatment. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. 2012;31(5):1032-1041. — 5.6-day water half-life, no tissue bioaccumulation (brown bullhead catfish, a rotenone-resistant species). — PubMed PMID: 22407799
  4. Redman ZC, Wesolowski J, Tomco PL. Photochemical pathways of rotenone and deguelin degradation: implications for rotenoid attenuation and persistence in high-latitude lakes. Environmental Science & Technology. 2021;55(8):4974-4983. — hours-scale half-lives under sunlight. — PubMed PMID: 33724011
  5. Cavoski I, Caboni P, Sarais G, Cabras P, Miano T. Photodegradation of rotenone in soils under environmental conditions. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2007;55(17):7069-7074. — 5–7 hour half-life under direct sunlight. — PubMed PMID: 17658825
  6. Melo KM, Oliveira R, Grisolia CK, Domingues I, Pieczarka JC, de Souza Filho J, Nagamachi CY. Short-term exposure to low doses of rotenone induces developmental, biochemical, behavioral, and histological changes in fish. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. 2015;22(18):13926-13938. — 96-hour zebrafish LC50 of 12.2 µg/L. — PubMed PMID: 25948382
  7. Sundara Rajoo K, Lepun P, Alan R, Singh Karam D, Abdu A, Rosli Z, Izani N, James Gerusu G. Ethnobotanical study of medicinal plants used by the Kenyah community of Borneo. Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 2023;301:115780. — records Derris elliptica use for fever and influenza. — PubMed PMID: 36202163
  8. Abd Rahman R, Jayasingh Chellammal HS, Ali Shah SA, Mohd Zohdi R, Ramachandran D, Mohsin HF. Exploring the therapeutic potential of Derris elliptica (Wall.) Benth in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats: phytochemical characterization and antidiabetic evaluation. Saudi Pharmaceutical Journal. 2024;32(4):102016. — PubMed PMID: 38463183
  9. Wiwattanapatapee R, Sae-Yun A, Petcharat J, Ovatlarnporn C, Itharat A. Development and evaluation of granule and emulsifiable concentrate formulations containing Derris elliptica extract for crop pest control. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2009;57(23):11234-11241. — PubMed PMID: 19904939
  10. Zhou Y, Wang K, Yan C, Li WS, Li H, Zhang N, Zhang ZX. Effect of two formulations on the decline curves and residue levels of rotenone in cabbage and soil under field conditions. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety. 2014;104:23-27. — PubMed PMID: 24632119
  11. Tat J, Heskett K, Boss GR. Acute rotenone poisoning: a scoping review. Heliyon. 2024;10(7):e28334. — PubMed PMID: 38633629
  12. Tanner CM, Kamel F, Ross GW, et al.. Rotenone, paraquat, and Parkinson's disease. Environmental Health Perspectives. 2011;119(6):866-872. — PubMed PMID: 21269927

Back to Table of Contents

Back to Table of Contents

External Resources

Back to Table of Contents

Connections

Back to Table of Contents