Grapes: Pesticides and the Choking Hazard

Whole grapes beside grapes cut into quarters
The page reports that cutting whole grapes lengthwise into quarters removes the choking hazard they pose to small children.
Infographic: choking hazard, quartering, pesticide residue and washing
The page compares the choking hazard of whole grapes for small children with the much-discussed pesticide residue question.
Colander of red grapes under running water
Rinsing grapes under running water is one of the washing methods the page examines.

Two safety questions come up about grapes, and they are wildly mismatched in how much attention each gets and how much each deserves. The one people worry about is pesticide residue — grapes appear year after year on a widely publicised list of the most contaminated produce, and that list has been the subject of serious peer-reviewed criticism that almost nobody reads alongside it. The one people rarely think about is the choking hazard a whole grape poses to a small child, which is a documented cause of paediatric death, has a fix that takes three seconds, and, as the paediatric literature below notes, is not widely known. This page gives both a fair hearing, and it puts the urgent one first.


Table of Contents

  1. Why a Grape Is the Worst Possible Shape
  2. What the Paediatric Record Shows
  3. Quartering Lengthwise Removes the Round Shape
  4. Other Foods With the Same Shape
  5. Grapes and a Widely Publicised Pesticide-Residue Ranking
  6. What the Peer-Reviewed Critiques Found
  7. How Much Buying Organic Changes Residue Exposure
  8. How the Estimated Benefits Compare With the Estimated Risks
  9. Washing: What Works and What Does Not
  10. Grapes Are Genuinely Dangerous to Dogs
  11. Other Practical Cautions
  12. Key Research Papers
  13. Connections
  14. Featured Videos

Why a Grape Is the Worst Possible Shape

A young child's airway is narrow — roughly the diameter of their own little finger — and it is not a rigid tube. Children under about five also have immature chewing and swallowing coordination, few or no molars for grinding, and a strong tendency to talk, laugh, run and be startled while eating. Any object that can reach the larynx before being chewed can lodge there.

A whole grape is close to the worst-case object, and it is worth spelling out why, because the reasons also identify every other food on the same list.

Deaths from choking are a major cause of childhood mortality, especially in the very young, and as the Aberdeen emergency physicians who wrote about this put it, whole grapes are "ideally suited to cause paediatric airway obstruction".

Back to Table of Contents

What the Paediatric Record Shows

This is not a theoretical risk raised by cautious people. It is documented in the clinical literature and in national paediatric guidance.

Lumsden and Cooper, emergency physicians at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, published a short paper in Archives of Disease in Childhood in 2017 under the title "The choking hazard of grapes: a plea for awareness". They described three children who presented to their department after grape aspiration, and their central observation was not about the mechanism — which is obvious once stated — but about awareness. Although grapes are regularly implicated in paediatric choking, they wrote, knowledge that this popular fruit and other similarly shaped foods pose a choking hazard is not widespread. They argued for wider dissemination among health professionals working with children. The fact that a case report in a major paediatric journal was needed to make this point tells you how far the message has travelled.

The American Academy of Pediatrics, through its Committee on Injury, Violence, and Poison Prevention, published a policy statement on the prevention of choking among children in Pediatrics in 2010, which sets out the food characteristics that make choking likely — round, cylindrical, compressible, smooth, slippery — and names the specific foods that combine them. Grapes and hot dogs are the archetypes. The statement opens by noting that choking is a leading cause of illness and death among children, “especially those aged 3 years or younger,” and that food, coins and toys are the primary causes of choking-related injury and death. Canadian paediatric guidance, summarised by Cyr in Paediatrics & Child Health in 2012, makes the same points about prevention.

The consistent theme across all of it is that this is a preventable injury, and that the prevention is trivial.

Back to Table of Contents

Quartering Lengthwise Removes the Round Shape

The preparation rule given for small children is specific.

For children under about five, the guidance is to cut grapes lengthwise into quarters — not crosswise into discs.

The direction of the cut is the entire point and it is the part people get wrong. A grape sliced crosswise gives round discs, which are still circular in cross-section and can still form a seal. A grape cut lengthwise, twice, gives pieces that are each a long thin wedge with no round profile in any orientation. A wedge cannot plug a tube.

Further points:

The Canadian Paediatric Society statement says paediatric health care providers should be encouraging parents and other caregivers to learn cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and choking first aid. Paediatric choking first aid — back blows and chest or abdominal thrusts appropriate to the child's age — is taught in hands-on courses rather than learned from a web page, this one included. A soft, wedged grape is notoriously difficult to dislodge, which is another reason prevention is so much better than response.

Back to Table of Contents

Other Foods With the Same Shape

The same pattern — round, smooth, compressible, airway-sized — identifies the other hazards. The commonly named ones for young children are:

None of this is a reason to keep fruit away from children. Grapes are a good food for a child, and cut correctly they are entirely safe. The point is that the preparation is what makes them safe.

Back to Table of Contents

Grapes and a Widely Publicised Pesticide-Residue Ranking

Now to the question that gets far more attention.

Each year a US environmental advocacy group publishes an annual pesticide-residue ranking of fruits and vegetables, naming the twelve it ranks worst and the fifteen it ranks cleanest. Grapes have appeared among its worst twelve consistently for many years, and imported table grapes typically rank among the produce items with the largest number of distinct residues detected.

That basic fact is not in dispute, and it deserves to be stated plainly rather than dismissed. Table grapes are a high-input crop. Vines are vulnerable to powdery mildew, downy mildew, botrytis bunch rot, mealybugs, mites and leafhoppers, so vineyards are sprayed repeatedly through a season. The fruit has a thin, waxy, absorbent skin, it is not peeled before eating, and its tight clusters trap spray residue in places that are hard to rinse. Multi-residue testing of table grapes routinely detects several different fungicides and insecticides on a single sample.

The advocacy group draws its data from a legitimate source: the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Pesticide Data Program, a large annual federal residue-monitoring programme whose results are public. Where the disagreement lies is not in the measurements but in what the ranking means and what it implies for shoppers.

Back to Table of Contents

What the Peer-Reviewed Critiques Found

The most-cited scientific analysis of that ranking is Winter and Katz, published in the Journal of Toxicology in 2011. It is worth walking through carefully, because it is quantitative and because its findings are rarely reported alongside the list itself.

The authors took the same U.S. Department of Agriculture Pesticide Data Program data and did something the ranking does not do: they calculated actual consumer exposure, using probabilistic modelling of how much of each commodity people eat, and compared it with the chronic reference dose for each pesticide — the daily exposure a regulator considers to carry no appreciable risk over a lifetime, itself set with large safety factors below the level where no effect is seen in animal studies. They ran this for the ten most frequently detected residues on each of the twelve commodities, giving 120 estimates.

Their results:

Their three conclusions were that exposures to the most commonly detected pesticides on these twelve commodities pose negligible risk to consumers; that substituting organic forms of the twelve for conventional forms does not appreciably reduce consumer risk; and — the sharpest of the three — that the methodology used to rank commodities by pesticide risk "lacks scientific credibility".

The methodological objection is the substantive one. The ranking is built largely on the frequency and number of residues detected, not on how toxic each residue is or how much of it is present. Detection technology has improved enormously; instruments now find residues at parts per billion that were invisible twenty years ago. A food can therefore rise up such a ranking because six different compounds were each detected at a thousandth of the level of regulatory concern, while a food with one residue closer to the limit ranks lower. Winter developed this argument further in the International Journal of Food Contamination in 2015, examining chronic dietary pesticide exposure across the American diet.

Two points stand on the other side. Reference doses are set one compound at a time, and the question of cumulative exposure to mixtures is a real and unresolved area of regulatory science — European regulators have been developing cumulative risk assessment methods for exactly this reason, and the annual European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) reports on pesticide residues in food discuss it. And people with occupational or residential exposure to agricultural spraying face an entirely different situation from a shopper eating a bunch of grapes; nothing here applies to farmworker exposure, which is a genuine and serious public-health issue in its own right. The site’s page on pesticides covers that wider picture.

Back to Table of Contents

How Much Buying Organic Changes Residue Exposure

The reviews point to a partial effect, smaller than most people expect.

Smith-Spangler and colleagues published a systematic review in Annals of Internal Medicine in 2012 asking whether organic foods are safer or healthier than conventional alternatives. On residues, the risk of contamination with detectable pesticide residues was lower among organic than conventional produce (risk difference, 30%), but differences in the risk of exceeding maximum allowed limits were small, and two studies reported significantly lower urinary pesticide levels among children eating organic rather than conventional diets. On nutrients, the review found little difference of consequence. On health outcomes, the evidence was insufficient to show that eating organic makes people healthier — which is not the same as showing it does not, but is where the evidence stood.

A 2019 US study measured exposure directly. In four families (16 children and adults, 158 urine samples), urinary levels of thirteen pesticide metabolites and parent compounds fell significantly after the families switched to an organic diet. The greatest reductions were for clothianidin (−82.7%), malathion dicarboxylic acid, a breakdown product of malathion (−95.0%), and 3,5,6-trichlor-2-pyridinol, a breakdown product of chlorpyrifos (−60.7%). The study measured urinary pesticide levels, not health outcomes.

Three points make this less decisive than it sounds:

  1. Organic farming uses pesticides too — approved substances of natural origin, including copper compounds, sulfur, spinosad and pyrethrins. "Organic" means a different list of permitted inputs, not an absence of pest control. Copper fungicide, heavily used in organic viticulture, accumulates in soil and is not benign.
  2. If conventional exposure is already three to six orders of magnitude below the level of concern, reducing it further has little room to matter, which is precisely what Winter and Katz argued.
  3. Cost matters, and it is a health variable. If organic grapes cost three times as much and the result is that a family buys less fruit, the substitution has made things worse rather than better.

The research summarised here does not support treating conventional grapes as dangerous. The reasons people give for choosing organic that have nothing to do with their own residue exposure — farmworker safety, water contamination, soil biology, biodiversity — stand on their own merits.

Back to Table of Contents

How the Estimated Benefits Compare With the Estimated Risks

One study puts the whole question in proportion better than any other. Reiss and colleagues, writing in Food and Chemical Toxicology in 2012, asked a directly practical question: if half the US population ate one more serving of fruit and one more of vegetables per day, how many cancer cases would be prevented — and how many might theoretically be caused by the extra pesticide residue that came with them?

They estimated the prevention side from a published meta-analysis of nutritional epidemiology, and the risk side using U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) methods, cancer potency estimates from rodent bioassays and U.S. Department of Agriculture residue sampling data. Their answer: approximately 20,000 cancer cases per year prevented, against up to 10 cancer cases per year potentially caused by the added pesticide intake.

The authors were candid about the uncertainties — residual confounding in observational fruit-and-vegetable epidemiology is a well-known problem, and extrapolating human cancer risk from high-dose rodent bioassays is contested in both directions. But the ratio here is not marginal. It is roughly two thousand to one, and no plausible correction to either estimate reverses the direction.

Reiss and colleagues concluded that the overwhelming difference between the benefit and risk estimates “provides confidence that consumers should not be concerned about cancer risks from consuming conventionally-grown fruits and vegetables.” On their estimates, the health risk of not eating the fruit is far larger than the health risk of the residue on it.

Back to Table of Contents

Washing: What Works and What Does Not

Washing matters mostly for reasons that have nothing to do with pesticides — dirt, handling, and the bacterial contamination that causes real and immediate illness.

Back to Table of Contents

Grapes Are Genuinely Dangerous to Dogs

This belongs on any grape safety page, because it is a real emergency and because the mechanism was only recently identified.

Grapes and raisins can cause acute kidney injury in dogs. The toxicity has been recognised clinically for decades, but it is unusual: some dogs eat grapes with no effect, others develop kidney failure after a small quantity, and no reliable toxic dose has ever been established. Schweighauser and colleagues described the clinical picture — acute kidney injury and neurological signs following grape or raisin ingestion — in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine in 2020. All 15 dogs with grape or raisin toxicosis in that study arrived with severe acute kidney injury. Eleven (73%) had marked forebrain, cerebellar or vestibular signs (problems with alertness, coordination or balance), which dominated the clinical picture in some dogs but were not associated with the severity of azotemia (waste build-up in the blood from failing kidneys). Eight dogs (53%) survived, and 5 dogs made a complete neurological recovery.

For years the responsible agent was unknown. In 2022 Wegenast and colleagues at the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center published a case series in the Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care that made the connection. They described four dogs that developed acute kidney injury after eating tamarinds and two after eating cream of tartar — two substances with nothing in common with grapes except one thing: tartaric acid and its salt, potassium bitartrate. Clinical signs, laboratory findings and the changes seen at necropsy closely matched those of grape and raisin toxicosis. The authors identified tartaric acid as the likely toxic principle. Grapes are unusually rich in it, dogs appear to be unusually sensitive to it, and the wide variation in tartaric acid content between grape varieties and ripeness would explain why the toxic dose has never been pinned down. The outcomes in that series were poor: two dogs became anuric, one oliguric, and four were euthanised.

Key points:

Back to Table of Contents

Other Practical Cautions

Back to Table of Contents

Key Research Papers

  1. Lumsden AJ, Cooper JG. The choking hazard of grapes: a plea for awareness. Archives of Disease in Childhood. 2017;102(5):473–474. — doi:10.1136/archdischild-2016-311750
  2. Committee on Injury, Violence, and Poison Prevention. Prevention of choking among children. Pediatrics. 2010;125(3):601–607. — doi:10.1542/peds.2009-2862
  3. Cyr C. Preventing choking and suffocation in children. Paediatrics & Child Health. 2012;17(2):91–92. — doi:10.1093/pch/17.2.91
  4. Winter CK, Katz JM. Dietary exposure to pesticide residues from commodities alleged to contain the highest contamination levels. Journal of Toxicology. 2011;2011:589674. — doi:10.1155/2011/589674
  5. Winter CK. Chronic dietary exposure to pesticide residues in the United States. International Journal of Food Contamination. 2015;2:11. — doi:10.1186/s40550-015-0018-y
  6. Reiss R, Johnston J, Tucker K, DeSesso JM, Keen CL. Estimation of cancer risks and benefits associated with a potential increased consumption of fruits and vegetables. Food and Chemical Toxicology. 2012;50(12):4421–4427. — doi:10.1016/j.fct.2012.08.055
  7. Smith-Spangler C, Brandeau ML, Hunter GE, et al. Are organic foods safer or healthier than conventional alternatives? A systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2012;157(5):348–366. — doi:10.7326/0003-4819-157-5-201209040-00007
  8. European Food Safety Authority, Medina-Pastor P, Triacchini G. The 2018 European Union report on pesticide residues in food. EFSA Journal. 2020;18(4):e06057. — doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2020.6057
  9. Wegenast CA, Meadows ID, Anderson RE, Southard T, González Barrientos CR, Wismer TA. Acute kidney injury in dogs following ingestion of cream of tartar and tamarinds and the connection to tartaric acid as the proposed toxic principle in grapes and raisins. Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care. 2022;32(6):812–816. — doi:10.1111/vec.13234
  10. Schweighauser A, Henke D, Oevermann A, Gurtner C, Francey T. Toxicosis with grapes or raisins causing acute kidney injury and neurological signs in dogs. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine. 2020;34(5):1957–1966. — doi:10.1111/jvim.15884
  11. Bates N, Tizzard Z, Edwards N. Acute kidney injury in dogs following ingestion of cream of tartar and tamarinds and the connection to tartaric acid as the proposed toxic principle in grapes and raisins (correspondence). Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care. 2023;33(6):722–723. — doi:10.1111/vec.13349
  12. Hyland C, Bradman A, Gerona R, et al. Organic diet intervention significantly reduces urinary pesticide levels in U.S. children and adults. Environmental Research. 2019;171:568–575. — PubMed PMID: 30765100
  13. Yang T, Doherty J, Zhao B, et al. Effectiveness of commercial and homemade washing agents in removing pesticide residues on and in apples. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 2017;65(44):9744–9752. — PubMed PMID: 29067814
  14. Primary data source — the USDA Pesticide Data Program annual residue monitoring results: USDA Agricultural Marketing Service: Pesticide Data Program
  15. Live literature search — paediatric food choking prevention: PubMed: paediatric food choking prevention
  16. Live literature search — dietary pesticide residue risk assessment: PubMed: dietary pesticide residue risk assessment

Back to Table of Contents

Connections

Back to Table of Contents